If you work in special education, you know how quickly a lesson can change. One minute, your small group is running smoothly. The next, a pencil flies across the room, a student drops to the floor, or someone yells “NO!” because it’s time to transition.
Challenging behaviors in special education can feel frustrating, exhausting, and sometimes completely unpredictable. But here’s something I remind myself of often: behavior is communication. Our students are usually trying to tell us something, even when they don’t yet have the skills to communicate it in a more appropriate way.
Maybe the work feels too hard. Maybe they don’t know what’s coming next. Maybe the classroom is too loud, they’re overwhelmed by a change in routine, or they need a break but don’t know how to ask for one.
When we start looking at behavior through that lens, our response begins to change. Instead of only asking, “How do I get this behavior to stop?” we can start asking, “What is this student trying to tell me, and what can I teach them to do instead?”
That’s where challenging behaviors can become teachable moments.
When a student engages in a challenging behavior, it’s easy to focus on the behavior we can see. The yelling. The refusal. The student who pushes their work away, leaves their seat, or shuts down completely.
But the behavior itself is only part of the story.
A student might be trying to say:
Instead of immediately thinking, How do I make this stop?, try asking yourself, What is this student trying to communicate?
For example, imagine Johnny regularly pushes his worksheet off the desk during independent work. We could look at that as simple work refusal. But when we look closer, we might notice it happens most often when he’s given writing assignments with multiple steps.
Now we have more information.
The assignment may feel overwhelming, and pushing it away may be the only strategy Johnny currently has for communicating, I can’t do this.
That doesn’t mean we remove every difficult task. It means we figure out what skill or support Johnny needs to handle the situation differently next time.
Maybe he needs to learn to:
The goal isn’t only to stop the challenging behavior. The goal is to teach a more functional way for the student to get their needs met.
When you’re trying to understand why a behavior is happening, take a step back and look at the bigger picture.
One way to do this is with the ABC approach:
Remember, consequence doesn’t necessarily mean punishment. It simply means what happened after the behavior.
Let’s say Sara is given a writing assignment. She looks at the paper, pushes it away, yells, and puts her head down. A staff member tells her she can take a break and removes the assignment.
Here’s what we might see:
Antecedent: Sara was given a writing assignment.
Behavior: Sara pushed the paper away, yelled, and put her head down.
Consequence: The assignment was removed, and Sara was given a break.
If this pattern happens repeatedly, we might start wondering whether Sara’s behavior is helping her escape or avoid a task she finds difficult.
Now we can think about what to teach instead.
Could Sara learn to hand over a break card? Could she ask for help? Could we break the assignment into smaller chunks and use a first/then visual so she knows exactly what she needs to complete?
When you notice a challenging behavior happening repeatedly, ask:
You don’t need to have all the answers immediately. Sometimes simply jotting down what happened before and after a behavior for several days can help you notice patterns you didn’t see before.
When a student is escalating, it can feel like you need to fix the situation immediately.
But in those high-stress moments, your first goal isn’t to solve the entire problem or teach a brand-new skill. Your first goal is to help the student get back to a place where they are regulated enough to learn.
Here are three things to focus on.
Before responding, take a breath.
Remember, the goal isn’t to win a power struggle. The goal is to help the student move toward regulation.
Keep your language short and clear. This usually isn’t the time for a long explanation or lecture about what the student should have done differently. You can have that conversation later when the student is calm and ready to learn.
A calm, even voice can communicate safety without removing expectations.
You might say:
The exact words will depend on the student and their communication level. Some students may respond to verbal directions, while others need fewer words and more visual support.
Staying calm doesn’t mean giving in. You can acknowledge that something is difficult while still helping the student work toward the expectation.
When the student is ready, use familiar supports to help them move forward.
This might include:
Instead of repeatedly saying, “You need to finish your work,” you might show the student:
FIRST: Complete 3 math problems
THEN: Take a 5-minute break
Or offer a simple choice:
“You can finish the three problems here, or you can finish them at the back table. You choose.”
The expectation hasn’t disappeared, but you’ve given the student some control over how they meet it.
And remember: a dysregulated student isn’t ready for a teachable moment yet.
Regulation first. Teaching second.
Once the student is calm and regulated, that’s when the real teaching can begin.
Keep the conversation short, neutral, and focused on one question:
What can the student do differently the next time this happens?
Let’s go back to Johnny. Maybe earlier in the day, Johnny became frustrated with an assignment and threw his paper on the floor.
Once he’s calm, you might say:
“Remember when your work felt hard earlier? Next time, instead of throwing your paper, you can show me your help card.”
Then comes the part we sometimes forget: practice it.
Don’t just tell Johnny what he should do next time. Give him an opportunity to practice the replacement behavior.
You might put another worksheet in front of him and say, “Let’s pretend this work feels really hard. What can you do?”
Johnny practices handing you the help card, and you immediately reinforce the appropriate communication.
“Great job telling me you need help!”
Now you’ve taken a challenging moment and turned it into an opportunity to teach a skill Johnny can use again.
A replacement behavior should give the student a more appropriate way to communicate or meet the need behind the challenging behavior.
For example:
The replacement behavior will look different for every student.
One student might say, “I need a break.”
Another might hand an adult a break card.
Another might point to a picture.
The goal is the same: give the student a functional way to communicate what they need.
And don’t wait until the student is already frustrated to teach the skill.
Practice replacement behaviors when the student is calm. Model them. Role-play them. Use visuals. Practice during predictable classroom routines and reinforce the student when they use the new skill.
We’re not just trying to reduce behavior. We’re building communication, self-advocacy, and independence.
While we can’t prevent every challenging behavior, we can often reduce frustration by making the classroom environment more structured and predictable.
Think about how stressful it feels when you don’t know what’s happening next, how long something will last, or when you’ll get a break. Our students can feel the same way, but they may not always have the communication skills to tell us.
That’s why proactive supports are so important.
Some of my favorite ways to add structure and predictability include:
The important thing is that these supports shouldn’t only appear after a challenging behavior occurs.
If we know that Sara struggles every day when it’s time to transition away from the computer, we don’t have to wait for her to become upset before offering support.
We might give her a five-minute warning, use a visual timer, show her what activity is coming next, and remind her of what she’s working toward.
Now Sara has more information. She knows the preferred activity is ending, she can see when it’s going to end, and she knows what is happening next.
Preventing challenging behaviors in special education often starts with creating more structure and predictability for students.
That predictability can make a difficult transition feel much more manageable.
For some students, knowing that reinforcement is coming isn’t enough. They need to see their progress toward it.
This is where token boards can be incredibly helpful.
A token board gives the student a concrete visual representation of their progress. Instead of repeatedly saying, “Just two more problems” or “Keep working and then you can have a break,” the student can actually see how close they are to earning their reinforcement.
If you’re looking for an easy way to start using token boards in your classroom, my Token Boards anad they are ready to use with students who benefit from a visual way to see their progress and stay motivated throughout a task.
If you’re new to using token boards, you can read my guide on How to Use Token Boards in a Special Education Classroom for more ideas on setting them up and using them effectively.
And if you’ve ever found yourself thinking, “But I’m using reinforcement and it’s STILL not working,” you’re definitely not alone. I also have a post about what to do when reinforcers aren’t working that can help you troubleshoot your reinforcement system.
The goal isn’t to fill your classroom with visuals just for the sake of having visuals. Every support should have a purpose.
Ask yourself:
What does this student need to understand or communicate more independently?
Then choose the visual or system that helps them do exactly that.
When students understand what is expected, know what is coming next, and have appropriate ways to communicate their needs, we create an environment where they have a better chance of being successful before challenging behaviWhile we can’t prevent every challenging behavior, we can often reduce frustration by making the classroom more structured and predictable.
Some of my favorite supports include:
The key is to use these supports proactively, not only after challenging behavior occurs.
If we know Sara struggles every day when it’s time to transition away from the computer, we don’t have to wait until she’s upset.
We might give her a five-minute warning, use a visual timer, show her what activity is coming next, and remind her of what she’s working toward.
Now Sara knows the preferred activity is ending, she can see when it’s going to end, and she knows what happens next.
That predictability can make a difficult transition much more manageable.
For some students, knowing reinforcement is coming isn’t enough. They need to see their progress toward it.
This is where token boards can be helpful.
Instead of repeatedly saying, “Just two more problems,” the student can see exactly how close they are to earning their reinforcement.
Of course, a token board is only effective if the student is motivated by what they’re working toward. Reinforcers can change over time, and what worked last month, last week, or even yesterday may not be motivating today.
If you’re new to using token boards, you can read my guide on How to Use Token Boards in a Special Education Classroom for more ideas on setting them up and using them effectively.
The Do’s and Don’ts for Using Token Boards
And if you’ve ever thought, “But I’m using reinforcement and it’s STILL not working,” I also have a post about what to do when reinforcers aren’t working that can help you troubleshoot your reinforcement system.
Read this blog post on Why Your Reinforcers Aren’t Working
Remember, the goal isn’t to fill your classroom with visuals just to have visuals.
Ask yourself:
What does this student need to understand or communicate more independently?
Then choose the support that helps them do exactly that.or even begins.
Sometimes you can do all the things and the challenging behavior is still happening.
First, take a breath. It doesn’t automatically mean you’re doing something wrong.
Behavior is complex, and students’ needs change. When a strategy stops working, step back and look for patterns again.
Ask yourself:
Also consider whether the support you’re using actually matches the reason the behavior is happening.
If Johnny throws his math work because the assignment is too difficult, offering a bigger reinforcer may not solve the problem. He may need additional instruction, differentiated work, or an appropriate way to ask for help.
When something isn’t working, go back to the basics. Look at what happens before and after the behavior. Collect data. Talk with your classroom team and related service providers.
You don’t need to have every answer immediately.
The goal isn’t a perfectly behaved classroom. The goal is to give students the skills and supports they need to become more successful and independent.
There is no perfect formula for handling challenging behaviors in special education. Even experienced special education teachers have moments when they wonder if they responded the right way.
What matters is that we keep trying to understand what our students are communicating.
Every time you teach a student to ask for a break instead of throwing their work, you’re building communication. Every time you use a visual to show what’s coming next, you’re building predictability. And every time you reinforce a replacement behavior, you’re helping that student become more independent.
So the next time a challenging behavior happens, pause and ask yourself:
“What is this behavior trying to tell me?”
When we approach behavior with curiosity, look for patterns, and intentionally teach missing skills, difficult moments can become opportunities for meaningful learning.
We aren’t just trying to manage behavior. We’re teaching our students better ways to communicate, advocate for themselves, and become more independent.
If you’re looking for more practical behavior strategies, check out my posts on using token boards in the special education classroom and what to do when your reinforcers aren’t working.
I am a High School, self-contained Autism teacher from Central New York, who is passionate about individualizing student learning. I am a mommy of three, lover of all things Disney, married to my best friend and addicted to chocolate!! I hope that you find great ideas and inspiration here, so welcome!!
Physical boxes will be shipped out on the first week of each month. If you purchase on the 2nd, your first box will not arrive until the next month. I.e. If you start your subscription January 15, your first box will arrive in February.
All subscriptions will receive immediate access to digital files.
Subscriptions are set to renew on the 1st of each month unless you opt for the annual plan.
